High turnover and inexperienced crews are testing construction safety. Experts point to supervision, onboarding and work planning as key pressure points.
Construction safety risks are increasingly tied to how firms organize work and train crews as experienced employees leave and new workers arrive. At the IRMI Construction Risk Conference in National Harbor, Maryland, experts said stricter safety programs alone won’t close the gap in practical knowledge affecting safety, quality and productivity. That distinction matters: a written rule can set expectations, but it can’t ensure a worker knows how a particular tool behaves or how a crew handles a task under pressure. This is more significant than it looks, because gaps in experience can reach beyond injury prevention and affect whether work is performed consistently.
Jesse Torres, corporate compliance safety director at Granite Construction in Watsonville, California, and Katie Stryker, a risk control specialist at CNA in Bloomington, Indiana, said companies need to prepare for a steady influx of workers with less industry experience. Stryker put the average age of construction workers at about 42.5. When experienced employees retire or are injured, their know-how goes with them; firms need to plan for those departures as well as replacement hiring. That knowledge often includes informal details: how a crew coordinates a handoff, spots a problem with a setup or adapts when a job doesn’t unfold as expected. A training checklist may record that a topic was covered, but it won’t by itself show whether that knowledge has reached the person doing the work.
Experience gaps reach the front line
The transition is also reshaping supervision. Torres said companies are promoting younger frontline supervisors quickly, in part because they’re comfortable with technology, then asking them to oversee production, safety and paperwork. Those duties can compete for a supervisor’s attention, particularly when a crew is moving quickly or the work changes. Rapid hiring and limited time to train supervisors can create what he called a “hurry-up mentality.” The concern isn’t simply that supervisors are young; it’s that responsibility can arrive faster than the practical experience needed to manage it.
Workers with less than a year on the job account for a majority of workers compensation claims, Stryker said, citing CNA claims and other workers compensation data. National Safety Council data she referenced show that about one-third of injuries resulting in missed work involve employees with less than a year of tenure. Those measures describe different outcomes, so they shouldn’t be treated as interchangeable. Taken together, though, they point to an elevated exposure period for workers who haven’t yet built familiarity with the job. For employers, the figures make onboarding a safety issue that deserves attention beyond the first orientation session.
That makes the definition of a “new worker” broader than a recent hire. The panelists included employees arriving from competitors, workers assigned unfamiliar tasks, seasonal and temporary staff, and people returning from an injury or leave. A person can know the industry and still be new to a particular site, crew, piece of equipment or assignment. That’s a useful distinction for managers: years of experience don’t automatically mean someone is ready for every task they’re given.
Risk shifts as workers settle in
The first 90 days can bring different exposure points, rather than one continuous period of identical risk. The first 30 days are especially difficult as workers learn a site and crew. As familiarity grows, workers may begin taking shortcuts; by around 60 days, supervisors may also reduce their oversight. Torres said Granite has seen more injuries in the 61-to-90-day period this year and is reviewing its data to understand the pattern. That timing challenges the assumption that risk falls steadily once a worker has passed initial training. Familiarity can help, but it can also bring confidence before a worker has mastered the hazards of a specific job.
Stryker cited a claim involving a Spanish-speaking rig hand who lost a foot on his fourth day. He had completed three days of classroom training but received no equipment-specific instruction. The panelists questioned whether the training could have been effective if delivered in English. The example underscores the difference between completing instruction and being prepared to perform the task: comprehension, language access and hands-on familiarity all matter. A classroom session may establish baseline expectations, but workers also need guidance that connects those expectations to the equipment and conditions they’ll encounter.
Work systems shape outcomes
The panelists urged firms to examine how work is organized instead of defaulting to worker blame. That approach shifts attention toward the conditions a company can examine: equipment choices, instructions, supervision and coordination among crews. Granite worked with a power tool manufacturer to standardize its tools, Torres said, reducing hand injuries and making instruction more consistent. Standardization can make it easier for workers to learn and for supervisors to give clear direction, though the reported result comes from Granite’s experience and doesn’t establish that the same change will produce the same outcome everywhere.
On sites with multiple contractors, Granite brings subcontractors into safety meetings early and treats them as partners. The timing matters because coordination problems can emerge where different crews share a worksite, responsibilities or equipment. Early discussion gives participants a chance to understand how the work will proceed and where instructions need to line up. Here’s the thing: a safety program depends on what people can follow in the flow of work, not only what the lead contractor has written down.
Keeping attention after onboarding
The practical challenge is sustaining attention after onboarding ends. Firms are tracking injuries among newer workers, including later in their first three months, while looking at whether supervision, language and task-specific training match the work crews actually face. A useful review has to ask when injuries occur and what the worker was doing, rather than treating every early-career incident as the same problem. (And this is the part most people overlook.) The measures are only useful if employers connect them to decisions about how work is assigned and supported.
For companies, the panelists’ account suggests that “new worker” status should be treated as a condition to reassess, not a label that expires after a short orientation. Someone returning from leave, moving to an unfamiliar task or joining a different crew may need renewed instruction and oversight. If you’re working in this space, the question is whether your training reflects the actual assignment and whether supervision continues as workers become more confident. That said, the article offers no single formula for addressing the problem. The signals are clear; the work is in identifying which parts of a company’s own system need attention.
Training completed. Work understood? That gap is where the panelists’ examples point: experience, communication and supervision have to meet the task at the jobsite, not just on paper.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.