Monday, November 16, 2026Analysis · Ideas · Culture
nova.cloudejoys.com Search Sections

BANKING

Anthem Website Tracking Suit Advances on Wiretap and Fiduciary Duty Claims

Published Oct 30, 2026875 readers

A judge let Anthem members pursue claims over website tracking, finding alleged privacy harm sufficient at this stage.

The ruling keeps two central claims alive in a proposed class action over Anthem’s website tracking. Members say tools on the insurer’s website and patient portal captured health-related searches and browsing activity, then sent that information to technology vendors. The court hasn’t decided whether the tracking was unlawful or whether members consented. For now, those questions remain open.

In Alexander-Fetterman v. Anthem Insurance Companies, Inc., filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, Judge Brookman declined on Wednesday to dismiss claims under the federal Wiretap Act and for breach of fiduciary duty. The members allege Anthem embedded tools from Adobe, Medallia and Quantum Metric in its website and patient portal. According to the complaint, those tools recorded searches including “hysterectomy” and “obstetrics/gynecology,” along with clicks and browsing activity, and transmitted the data to the vendors. The complaint says Anthem used the information to market its plans and increase enrollment and revenue. Those are allegations, not findings established by the ruling.

The case sits at the intersection of familiar digital practices and unusually sensitive information. Websites commonly use analytics and marketing tools to measure visitor activity, but searches about medical care can reveal more than general interest in a product. The legal dispute turns in part on what was collected, how it was transmitted, and what the website’s terms told users about that process.

Consent and privacy harm remain disputed

Anthem, based in Indianapolis, argued that members accepted the tracking by using its website. Brookman said the record was too limited to resolve that question. He pointed to terms of use that neither mention nor link to the privacy policies, and questioned why continued site use would establish acceptance of those policies. That gap matters because a company’s claim of consent depends not only on user conduct, but also on what users were given a fair chance to understand.

The ruling doesn’t settle what disclosure would be sufficient, or whether members actually saw any privacy policy. It does mean Anthem’s account of consent couldn’t carry the day at this stage. Website operators often rely on notices and terms to explain data collection; when those documents don’t clearly connect to the tracking at issue, the question of what a user agreed to can become contested. Here, the judge found the available record insufficient to resolve it.

The judge also rejected Anthem’s contention that search terms fall outside the Wiretap Act’s protection for the “contents” of communications. He said alleged violations of the federal health privacy law HIPAA could support liability under the act, without proof that Anthem acted specifically to violate the law rather than to make money. That ruling addresses the legal theory presented at this stage; it doesn’t establish that a HIPAA violation occurred or that Anthem is liable.

The members’ alleged loss of privacy was sufficient to establish harm at this stage. That threshold matters because a case can’t proceed on an abstract disagreement alone: plaintiffs must describe an injury the court can recognize. The judge’s decision leaves the privacy claim in play, while the underlying facts and the reach of any eventual remedy remain unresolved. This is more significant than it looks: it keeps the dispute focused on whether health-related searches can be treated as protected communications even when collected through ordinary website tools.

Two claims dismissed

The court dismissed unjust enrichment because the plaintiffs didn’t allege they expected payment for their data, but allowed them to refile that claim. The distinction is narrow but practical. A claim based on a company’s alleged benefit from user information still needs a legal basis for saying that benefit should be returned; the court found the current allegations didn’t show an expectation of payment. The opportunity to refile leaves the plaintiffs room to try to address that defect.

It dismissed the intrusion upon seclusion claim with prejudice: Indiana law requires an intrusion into physical space, while the complaint describes activity in a “digital space.” That result reflects the limits of the particular state-law claim as presented. It doesn’t decide whether the same alleged tracking can support other legal theories, including the two that survived. A digital privacy complaint can therefore face different outcomes across claims, depending on what each law requires.

What the surviving claims could turn on

The surviving claims now turn on whether the plaintiffs can substantiate their allegations and establish that Anthem’s tracking violated the law. The ruling doesn’t establish how many members were affected, what information each vendor received, or whether the data was used in the way the complaint alleges. Those details may shape how the claims develop, but the source material doesn’t establish them.

Adobe is based in San Jose, Quantum Metric in Monument, Colorado, and Medallia in McLean, Virginia. Their alleged role as recipients of website data adds another layer to the dispute, though the ruling described here concerns the claims against Anthem and doesn’t resolve the vendors’ conduct. For companies that use third-party tools on health-related pages, the case underscores a basic operational question: do the notices and technical practices tell the same story about what data leaves the site?

If you’re working in this space, the key point is that ordinary analytics can become a legal issue when the activity being measured reveals sensitive interests and the consent record is unclear. And this is the part most people overlook: the court hasn’t answered whether members consented. It has said the available record doesn’t answer that question yet.

Source: Richard Sine · www.businessinsurance.com

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.