California’s revised proposal sets attorney rate caps by experience and permits limited billing for travel and transcript review.
Rates vary by experience
California’s revised proposal would set statewide maximum rates for attorneys taking depositions in workers’ compensation cases, with the ceiling tied to experience and specialist status. Released Wednesday by the California Division of Workers’ Compensation, the draft sets a maximum of $500 per hour for attorneys certified as workers’ compensation specialists by the State Bar of California. Attorneys with at least 10 years handling California workers’ compensation cases could charge up to $450 per hour; those with five to 10 years, $400; and those with less than five years, $350. These are proposed limits on deposition fees, not a statement of what every attorney charges or what every deposition will cost.
The tiered structure makes experience a central part of the proposed fee framework. It also places certified specialists in a separate category, with a higher ceiling than the experience-based tiers. That distinction may reflect the division’s effort to account for differing levels of relevant expertise while giving parties a statewide reference point. The draft doesn’t explain how the categories would apply in every possible case, so the practical effect would depend on how the final rules define and implement them.
That structure differs from the January draft, which proposed a $450 cap for attorneys with at least five years of experience and $400 for those with less. The revised version separates attorneys with five to 10 years from those with at least 10, and it raises the proposed maximum for certified specialists. This is more significant than it looks: changing the number of tiers can affect how a fee dispute is framed, even when the rules still set only maximum rates.
More billable work, broader scope
The revised rules would let attorneys bill for deposition travel and transcript review at up to half their applicable maximum rate, provided they document the work. The January version barred payment for both activities. The change recognizes that a deposition can involve work beyond the time spent asking questions, while the documentation condition gives the paying party a basis to assess whether the added charge reflects work performed.
The distinction matters because a rate cap and a limit on billable activities answer different questions. A cap sets the highest hourly rate that may apply; it doesn’t, by itself, determine which tasks qualify for payment or how much time can be billed. The revised draft addresses both sides to some extent: it permits two categories of additional work, but ties that permission to the applicable rate and proof. That said, the proposal doesn’t establish from the information available here how much travel or transcript review will be considered reasonable in a particular case.
The new draft also removes proposed limits on billing increments and minimum or flat fees, drops a $250 hourly cap for non-attorney representatives, and expressly covers people claiming dependent benefits. Those changes widen the proposal’s reach beyond the attorney rate schedule. Removing restrictions could leave more room for parties to set or contest billing practices, while expressly including dependent-benefit claimants clarifies that the proposal addresses more than injured workers alone. The consequences will turn on the final wording and on how the rules interact with the existing fee process.
(And this is the part most people overlook.) A statewide maximum can make comparisons easier, but it won’t settle every disagreement about a bill. Parties may still differ over whether particular work was necessary, whether it was documented adequately, or which rate tier applies. Clearer ceilings may narrow one part of a dispute. The underlying question of what counts as reasonable work remains.
From local guidance to statewide ranges
Current law requires employers and insurers to pay reasonable attorney fees when they request depositions of represented injured workers or people claiming dependent benefits. Local policies set by presiding workers’ compensation judges guide those fees, which can lead to disputes and litigation. The proposed rules would establish statewide rate ranges under Labor Code Section 5710.
That shift would give parties a common statewide framework where local policies currently guide fees. In practice, common limits can make the starting point for a fee discussion more predictable, particularly when a deposition involves representatives from different locations or when parties disagree about the applicable rate. But a statewide schedule doesn’t automatically remove judgment from the process. The proposal’s use of maximum rates, documentation, and experience categories leaves questions that may still need to be resolved case by case.
If you’re working in this space, the key distinction is between a rule that sets an upper bound and one that fixes a final fee. The draft describes maximum rates and permits specified additional billing; it doesn’t say that every charge at or below the cap must be paid. Reasonableness remains part of the existing standard. A schedule can reduce uncertainty around rates while leaving the parties to document and debate the work itself.
What the proposal could mean next
Public comments are due by 5 p.m. Nov. 9. The division must complete formal rulemaking before the regulations can take effect, leaving the proposed caps subject to change. The draft is therefore a proposal, not a settled statewide fee schedule. Its current details show the direction of the division’s revisions, but they don’t establish the final terms or an effective date.
The next stage matters because the draft combines several policy choices: how experience affects the ceiling, whether specialist status warrants a higher maximum, which related tasks may be billed, and how broadly the rules cover representatives and claimants. Comments could address any of those elements, though the available information doesn’t indicate what changes the division will make. For now, the clearest signal is that the division has moved away from the January draft’s simpler experience split and its categorical bar on travel and transcript-review charges.
There’s still room for revision. The final rules will determine whether the proposed ranges offer a workable statewide reference and how much disagreement remains over the work behind each bill. Until formal rulemaking is complete, parties have a draft to assess, not a final rate structure.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.