Insurance leaders say shared claims data and consumer education could clarify how litigation practices affect insurer costs and premiums.
Insurers and regulators see better data sharing as a way to measure litigation costs they associate with legal-system abuse and explain their potential effect on premiums. That was the focus of a Tuesday panel at the American Property Casualty Insurance Association’s annual meeting. The discussion centered on a practical problem: insurers can make claims about costs, but regulators and consumers have limited grounds to assess those claims if the underlying information isn’t available for scrutiny. Better data could give the debate a firmer footing, though sharing information alone wouldn’t settle disagreements over which legal practices drive costs or how much they contribute.
Louisiana Insurance Commissioner Tim Temple said quantifying the costs would help sustain efforts to address the practices. “There’s got to be more information. You’ve got to share more data,” he said. His argument links measurement to political durability: efforts to change practices are harder to maintain when their claimed costs can’t be clearly shown. But the kind of information collected matters. Cost totals, for example, may describe the scale of an expense without explaining which cases, procedures, or other factors account for it. A useful evidence base would need enough detail to support meaningful comparisons while making clear what the figures do and don’t establish.
Mark Afable, a principal at Chicago-based Afable Consulting and former Wisconsin insurance commissioner, also called for regulators to receive the data behind insurers’ claims. “We need the numbers,” he said. The request puts regulators in the role of examining the support for industry statements, rather than relying only on broad descriptions of litigation costs. That distinction is significant: a claim can sound persuasive in public debate and still leave open questions about its scope, methods, or relationship to premiums. Regulators’ access to the underlying numbers could help them test those claims, although the panel discussion didn’t specify what data insurers should provide or how the information should be presented.
Public education is another proposed response
Panelists said insurers and regulators could work together to explain how litigation costs may feed into insurance premiums. Dana Popish Severinghaus, a partner at Noted Advisory and former director of the Illinois Department of Insurance, pointed to educational partnerships as an opportunity to show consumers what contributes to insurance costs. The proposal recognizes that premiums can reflect several cost pressures, and that a discussion focused on only one may leave consumers with an incomplete picture. For an educational effort to be useful, it would need to distinguish what’s measured from what’s inferred, and explain where the available evidence remains uncertain.
That distinction matters because a connection between litigation expenses and premiums isn’t self-explanatory. Consumers may hear that a cost exists and assume its effect on their own bill is direct or uniform. The panel’s stated aim was to explain potential effects, not to provide a specific calculation of how much premiums change because of litigation. That restraint should shape any public message. Clear explanations can help people follow the argument; broad claims without supporting detail may instead deepen distrust.
Afable also said insurers need to respond more effectively to advertising by plaintiffs attorneys that targets the industry. His point adds a communications problem to the data problem: insurers may believe public claims about the industry are misleading, but a rebuttal will carry limited weight if it doesn’t offer evidence readers can examine. The panel discussion didn’t describe particular advertisements or propose a specific response. It did, however, raise a familiar challenge in contested policy debates: the side that communicates more forcefully can shape public understanding, while the side with better evidence still has to make that evidence accessible.
The discussion points to two priorities for insurers: build a clearer evidence base on litigation expenses and communicate their cost implications to consumers. Those priorities are related, but they’re not interchangeable. Better explanations can’t compensate for weak or incomplete data, and detailed data won’t automatically give consumers a clear account of what affects premiums. The work would involve deciding what to measure, making the basis for claims understandable, and presenting the limits of the evidence alongside the conclusions.
What better data could—and couldn’t—show
In insurance debates, costs are often discussed as if they move directly from one part of the system to a customer’s premium. The path can be more complicated. Similar cost questions typically require analysts to separate the expense being measured from other factors that may also affect prices, then explain the connection in plain terms. That doesn’t mean litigation expenses can’t matter. It means a credible account needs to show how the conclusion follows from the numbers, rather than asking the audience to accept the connection on assertion alone.
Here’s the thing: data sharing is a starting point, not a verdict. Regulators would need to understand what the figures cover and whether the categories are consistent enough to compare. Insurers, in turn, would need to explain how they use the information to support public claims. If you're working in this space, the credibility of the exercise may depend as much on those definitions and explanations as on the volume of data released.
There’s also a difference between making information available and making it useful to consumers. Detailed records can be difficult to interpret without context, while simplified summaries can conceal important qualifications. A partnership between insurers and regulators could help bridge that gap, provided it doesn’t blur their different roles. Regulators can examine claims; insurers can explain their cost arguments; public education can make the underlying reasoning legible. Each step depends on the evidence being clear enough to withstand questions from people who don’t already agree.
This is more significant than it looks. The panel wasn’t just discussing how to describe litigation costs; it was asking what evidence should support an argument with consequences for public understanding of insurance prices. And yet, the comments reported from the meeting leave key practical details open, including what information should be shared and how its effect on premiums should be assessed. For now, the direction is clear, while the method remains to be worked out. A better record could sharpen the debate. By itself, though, it won’t tell consumers how much of their premium reflects any single cost.
That’s the gap the proposed work would have to address: a chain of reasoning that begins with documented expenses and ends with a careful explanation of possible premium effects. The numbers, if shared, would be the foundation. The explanation would still need to show what they mean—and what they don’t. A useful public account.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.