Monday, November 16, 2026Analysis · Ideas · Culture
nova.cloudejoys.com Search Sections

ECONOMY

Evaluating the Impact of US Scrap Regulations on Domestic Mineral Supply

Published Aug 23, 2026306 readers

US regulations on critical-mineral scrap aim to enhance domestic supply security, but their effectiveness hinges on actual recovery and processing capabilities.

The United States is taking proactive measures to retain critical-mineral scrap within its borders. While the intention is to bolster supply security, the real test lies not in the volume of material retained, but in the capacity of the domestic industry to convert this scrap into usable minerals. In late August, new regulations will require certain types of scrap, such as lithium-ion battery waste and tungsten, to be sold to US entities unless specific exemptions are granted.

The rationale here is straightforward: if the US is in urgent need of critical minerals, exporting scrap that already contains these minerals seems counterproductive. However, scrap must undergo a series of processes, including collection, sorting, and refining, before it can become usable by sectors like battery manufacturing, defense, and industrial applications.

Assessing Usable Supply

Recycling has the potential to enhance mineral security, yet it cannot fully eliminate the necessity for primary mining and refinement. The International Energy Agency (IEA) suggests that increased recycling efforts could decrease the need for new mining developments by approximately 40% for copper and cobalt, and around 25% for lithium and nickel by 2050 under its energy-transition forecasts.

These reductions are notable, but they still leave significant demand for primary production. It's critical to emphasize that one tonne of black mass does not correspond directly to one tonne of lithium, nickel, or cobalt. The ultimate value of this material relies heavily on its chemical composition, metal content, collection and sorting methods, recovery costs, and whether the final product meets customer standards.

Insights from GEM Mining Consulting highlight the importance of distinguishing between the mere amount of scrap retained and the actual supply of refined minerals. A significant quantity of secondary material does not automatically translate into economic resources. Factors such as grade, recovery efficiency, energy consumption, capital expenditures (CAPEX), operational expenses (OPEX), regulatory challenges, and execution risk all influence the transformation of this material into saleable products.

Understanding Recovery Challenges

GEM identifies a critical metric they term “recoverable strategic supply.” This framework requires material to navigate five essential hurdles to become viable: it must be accessible, properly collected and sorted, supported by domestic processing capabilities, technically and economically recoverable, and ultimately able to yield products that meet domestic customer specifications.

While the US regulations mainly address the first hurdle by ensuring more feedstock remains within the country, they do not inherently enhance collection methods, build processing infrastructure, or guarantee successful recovery rates or product qualification.

The pressing bottleneck can shift rapidly. According to the most comprehensive data from the US Department of Energy for 2023, facilities across the country could manage nearly 175,000 tons of batteries and manufacturing scrap. However, only about 35,500 tons of this capacity is geared toward recovering battery materials, with an additional 76,000 tons of recovery capacity anticipated to come online over the next few years. These figures highlight a significant gap between mere shredding of batteries into black mass and the recovery of key minerals into fully usable products.

Timing is another complicating factor. The IEA warns that global recycling capacity is growing faster than the available feedstock. If all currently announced projects get completed, by 2030, capacity could exceed feedstock by seven times. After 2030, however, this narrative will likely shift as more electric-vehicle batteries reach the end of their lifecycle, and current projections suggest recycling capacity will only cover about 30% of available feedstock by 2040.

Navigating Export Restrictions

This mismatch presents a challenging scenario for investment. Developing recovery capacity too late could stymie the process, while premature construction may leave facilities scrambling for economic feedstock. During this transition, export limitations come into play. The OECD reports a fivefold increase in restrictions on critical raw materials between 2009 and 2024, with waste and scrap materials as the most frequently targeted category. Europe is also tightening regulations around battery waste and black mass.

Conversely, maintaining some degree of international scrap trade can actually support the scalability and operational efficiency of recycling facilities. If export restrictions are imposed before a competitive domestic recycling capacity is established, there's a risk that materials might end up underutilized or processed less efficiently. This could inadvertently lead to a greater demand for newly mined materials than policymakers anticipate.

Tungsten illustrates another aspect of the supply challenge. The US Geological Survey notes that tungsten has not been commercially mined domestically since 2015. Yet, several US companies are positioned to convert concentrates, ammonium paratungstate, and tungsten scrap into various tungsten products. In 2025, recycling is expected to constitute the sole source of tungsten supply in the country.

The divergence in supply chain maturity between black mass and tungsten scrap is notable. Despite falling under similar policy regulations, these materials enter supply chains at different readiness levels. Thus, focusing solely on tonnage may obscure the actual strategic benefits derived from these policies.

Revising Metrics for Better Insight

To assess the efficacy of these regulations, GEM proposes a more informative metric called the “scrap-to-security conversion ratio.” This ratio measures the qualified domestic secondary mineral output relative to the critical-mineral content retained due to the new policies, calculated using contained mineral units rather than gross tonnes.

For instance, if the policy retains scrap containing 100 units of critical minerals, and 68 of these units are eventually improved to meet consumer specifications after processing, the conversion ratio is an impressive 68%. This figure presents a far clearer picture of supply security than the original 100 units.

Currently, public datasets lack the granularity needed to calculate such a ratio on a national scale, representing an opportunity for policymakers to step in. By improving the tracking of mineral content through various stages—collection, pre-treatment, recovery, and final qualification—these regulations could be evaluated more effectively.

Such measures align well with GEM's broader research into strategic mineral stockpiling, which suggests that stockpiling can best support a resilient strategy encompassing recycling, diversification, and substitution. The principles of clear governance and industry coordination play a crucial role in this context.

While retaining scrap can provide a distributed feedstock model akin to stockpiling, its true value will hinge on the domestic system's capacity to convert this scrap into usable materials. More importantly, as GEM's previous studies indicate, there’s a gap between what is technically achievable and what can achieve significance at market scale driven by economic factors.

The US Department of Energy has offered substantial financial backing—up to $500 million for projects aimed at domestic critical-material processing and recycling—an initiative that could catalyze increased private investment and more reliable access to feedstock.

Yet, the mere presence of export restrictions is not a silver bullet for establishing a cohesive recycling industry. Both black mass and tungsten scrap must traverse the entire production chain effectively and economically. For stakeholders—miners, investors, and government entities—it’s essential to realize that while secondary supply is expected to expand, merely holding onto scrap doesn’t indicate how swiftly recycling can supplant primary mining needs.

The query must shift from how much critical mineral scrap the US can retain, to how much usable mineral supply can be generated from the retained material. This perspective encapsulates the essence of integrating circularity into supply security, establishing the foundation upon which these policies should be evaluated.


Alina Karpunina is project manager at GEM Mining Consulting.

Source: Cecilia Jamasmie · www.mining.com

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.