Monday, November 16, 2026Analysis · Ideas · Culture
nova.cloudejoys.com Search Sections

INVESTING

AI Could Reshape Women’s Roles in Insurance Claims and Underwriting

Published Oct 30, 2026503 readers

AI may automate routine insurance work, while training, customer skills and sponsorship could help women navigate changing roles.

AI Could Reshape Women’s Roles in Insurance Claims and Underwriting

AI puts job quality in focus

AI adoption in insurance puts a business decision in sharper focus: whether automation creates room for higher-value work or simply adds more tasks to employees’ workloads. That choice could have particular consequences for women, who hold a disproportionate share of administrative roles in claims and underwriting. When routine duties change, the effects can reach beyond efficiency: they can alter what a job asks of employees, which skills employers reward, and who gets a path into more senior work. The technology alone won’t settle those questions. Management decisions will.

Speakers at Thursday’s Business Insurance Women to Watch Leadership Conference urged insurers to improve jobs with AI rather than treat the technology mainly as a way to cut positions. Michelle Raue, founder of Nashville-based Raue Strategic Advisory, said AI can take on repetitive tasks and give claims staff more time with policyholders. “People have a loss, and they want to tell a human about their loss,” she said. That distinction matters in insurance, where a claim can involve both paperwork and a person trying to understand what happens next. Automating administrative steps may free staff to listen, explain processes and handle questions that don’t fit a routine workflow.

But efficiency isn’t the same as better service. If saved time is immediately filled with more cases or faster turnaround expectations, the employee may have less opportunity to give each policyholder attention. The customer-facing benefit Raue described depends on how the work is reorganized after automation, and on whether managers treat freed capacity as time that can be spent differently. A tool can remove a task; it can’t decide what the organization values instead.

That potential benefit depends on how employers use the capacity automation creates. Ema Roloff, cofounder and chief growth officer of Madison, Wisconsin-based Roloff Consulting, said earlier technology shifts have often removed manual tasks only to load employees with more work. “Instead of opening up capacity for what most people would see as the more important work, we’re shoving more work onto people’s plates,” she said. Her warning points to a familiar workplace tension: productivity gains can accrue to the organization while the daily workload remains just as demanding for staff. If you're working in this space, the relevant question is not only what AI can complete, but what your employer expects you to do with the time it saves.

Experience still matters

Women may face greater exposure to displacement if routine administrative work shrinks. But Roloff said their insurance knowledge, communication skills and customer relationships could carry more weight as AI handles routine tasks. Those strengths are built through experience and can help employees spot when a case needs judgment or a more careful conversation. They aren’t guaranteed protection, however: their value depends on whether companies recognize them in job design and career decisions. Companies that focus too narrowly on eliminating roles risk losing employees who understand the business and its customers.

This is more significant than it looks. Administrative work can be treated as a collection of repeatable steps, but employees doing that work may also have practical knowledge of how claims and underwriting processes operate. When automation changes those jobs, employers need to consider which parts of that knowledge remain useful and how employees can apply it elsewhere. A staffing decision based only on tasks that software can perform may miss the judgment and customer context accumulated around those tasks.

Making that transition also requires time to learn. Raue said heavy workloads can leave women with little room to experiment with AI, making employer training especially important. Training can help staff understand where a tool fits into their work, what tasks still require human judgment and how responsibilities may change. Without time to learn, the employees most affected by new systems may have the least chance to shape how those systems are used. That’s a practical management problem, not a question of whether workers are willing to adapt.

She encouraged employees whose companies don’t offer learning opportunities to build those skills themselves, arguing that AI fluency can make them more valuable. That advice puts responsibility on individuals, but it doesn’t remove the employer’s role in setting expectations and making learning possible. A worker can seek out new skills and still have little room to use them if workload and job duties don’t change. Training, in other words, is only part of the transition.

Raue also warned that resisting AI outright could increase the chance that employers replace workers with the technology. Her point puts the focus on adaptation: employees need opportunities to learn how AI changes their work, while employers need to decide whether those changes improve service and job quality. There’s a tension here. Workers may be urged to become fluent in tools that could alter or reduce parts of their roles, while the organization controls how those tools are adopted. The answer lies partly in whether employees have a meaningful place in that process. Not just access to a tool, but a say in how the work changes.

Sponsorship and career mobility

Professional networks can help women respond as roles change, said Lorene Phillips, founder of Bermuda-based consultancy Clarendon Wallace. “Build your network before you need it,” she said in a separate presentation. She advised women to seek senior sponsors who will use their influence to advocate for them and help open career opportunities, rather than waiting to be noticed. Sponsorship can connect an employee’s experience to decision-makers who shape assignments and advancement. It can also make existing skills more visible when job requirements are being reconsidered.

Networks won’t resolve questions about staffing or training, and sponsorship can’t guarantee a particular career outcome. Still, Phillips’ advice addresses a point that can get lost in discussions of technology: access to new responsibilities often depends on who knows an employee’s work and is prepared to speak for them. As job descriptions shift, people with advocates may have an easier time making the case that their experience fits emerging roles. The people without those connections may need employers to make career paths clearer.

What insurers do with the capacity matters

For insurers, the measure of AI’s value will depend partly on what happens after routine tasks are automated: whether employees gain time for policyholders and more complex work, or simply inherit a heavier workload. Employers will have to make that result visible in the way they organize roles, support learning and evaluate performance. If the stated aim is better service, then employees need enough time to provide it. If the aim is a leaner operation, workers will feel that choice in their responsibilities.

For women in the sector, AI skills and active sponsorship may help preserve career options as that balance shifts. Yet individual preparation can only go so far when employers control the tools, workloads and opportunities to advance. The conference speakers’ arguments point to a broader test for the industry: whether AI changes the quality and direction of work, or merely changes how quickly employees are expected to complete it. That answer will emerge from workplace decisions, not from the technology’s capabilities alone.

Source: Gavin Souter · www.businessinsurance.com

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.