Monday, November 16, 2026Analysis · Ideas · Culture
nova.cloudejoys.com Search Sections

INVESTING

Medical Malpractice Insurance Rates Rise 1.8% as Underwriting Losses Persist

Published Oct 30, 2026850 readers

Medical malpractice rates rose 1.8% at midyear 2026, while insurers recorded a 12th straight year of underwriting losses.

Losses persist as rates edge higher

Medical professional liability insurers continued to absorb underwriting losses in 2025, yet premium increases remained modest at midyear 2026. Rates rose an average of 1.8%, according to Medical Liability Monitor’s 36th annual survey, slightly below the 1.9% increase reported a year earlier. The gap is small, but the direction matters: reported premiums are still rising, while the pace of increase hasn’t accelerated alongside the sector’s persistent underwriting losses.

That combination deserves attention. An insurer’s underwriting result reflects the relationship between premiums collected and claims and other costs incurred in writing coverage. A rising premium can help offset higher losses, but the headline rate change doesn’t show whether the increase is sufficient for any particular insurer, specialty, or policyholder. Nor does a market average mean each physician is seeing a similar renewal. The survey’s figures describe a broad pattern, not a uniform price.

What the combined ratio says

The underwriting picture is tougher: the sector’s combined ratio reached 107.4% in 2025, its 12th consecutive year of underwriting losses. A combined ratio above 100% indicates that claims and associated expenses exceeded the premiums earned over the period measured. Put plainly, the core insurance operation paid out more than it brought in through premiums. The ratio is a useful pressure gauge, though it doesn’t by itself explain how results vary among carriers or lines of business.

Rising claim severity and larger court awards and settlements are adding pressure. Severity concerns the cost of claims, rather than simply how many claims are made. When individual claims become more expensive, insurers can face higher expected costs even if claim frequency doesn’t rise. That distinction helps explain why a market can be under pressure without the available figures identifying a surge in the number of claims.

Claims-made coverage also requires attention to timing. The survey tracks mature claims-made premiums, a defined basis for comparing prices that accounts for the policy form and its maturity. Readers shouldn’t treat those figures as a direct quote for every policy or assume they capture every factor affecting a particular account. Specialty, coverage details, claims experience, and the insurer’s own pricing approach can all matter, but the source doesn’t quantify their individual effects.

Competition complicates pricing

Competition is limiting pricing power, with some carriers lowering premiums to hold or gain market share. Here’s the thing: insurers can face rising costs and still choose restrained pricing if they believe a sharper increase could cost them business. That choice may help explain why an industrywide underwriting problem doesn’t automatically translate into large increases across the board. Pricing reflects both the cost of risk and the commercial contest for policyholders.

This is more significant than it looks. Persistent losses suggest that the sector hasn’t yet matched premiums to the claims burden in aggregate, while competitive pressure can make that adjustment uneven. A carrier may have different expectations, costs, and appetite for business than a rival. The survey doesn’t establish why any individual company changed a rate, so it would be a mistake to read a modest average increase as proof that every insurer is taking the same view.

And yet, competitive restraint has limits as a description of the whole market. Some rates are increasing, some are unchanged, and some are falling. That mix can coexist with rising claims costs because insurers don’t set all premiums at one common level. The reported results show dispersion in pricing decisions, not a single market-wide response.

Rate changes reveal a mixed market

About 38% of reported rates increased, up from 35% in 2025; 53% were unchanged, and 9% declined. These shares put the 1.8% average in context. Most reported rates didn’t change, while a larger share rose than in the prior survey, and a smaller portion fell. The average describes the size of increases across the measure; the shares describe how widely rate changes were distributed. Neither measure alone tells the full story.

The figures point to a market where loss costs are rising but insurers’ ability to pass them through remains uneven. An unchanged rate isn’t necessarily evidence that an insurer’s costs are flat; it may reflect a pricing decision under competition or other factors not detailed in the source. A declining rate also doesn’t erase the sector’s aggregate underwriting loss. It identifies a price movement, not the financial result for a particular carrier.

If you’re working in this space, the distinction between direction and breadth is useful. The average increase is modest, but more reported rates rose than in the previous year. At the same time, the unchanged majority indicates that many observations did not move at all. A single percentage can conceal that spread.

What the survey measures

Conducted with the Medical Professional Liability Association, the survey tracks mature claims-made premiums for internal medicine, general surgery and obstetrics/gynecology, based on limits of $1 million per claim and $3 million annually. Rates are measured as of July 1. Those details define the comparison: the results relate to specified specialties, coverage limits, and a particular point in time. They shouldn’t be read as a complete census of every medical professional liability policy or as a forecast of future renewal prices.

This year’s report also provides a second year of comparative premium data for nurse practitioners and reviews pricing across the broader medical professional liability market. A second year of comparisons can give readers another point of reference, but it remains a short record for judging a durable trend. The survey’s broader review may offer additional context, although the source provided here doesn’t describe its findings in detail.

That said, the defined sample is part of what makes the figures interpretable. Comparing rates for the same stated limits and specialties helps readers understand what the survey is measuring. It also sets boundaries on what can be inferred. Differences outside the measured categories may not be visible in the headline average.

Implications and outlook

The figures leave a clear tension: underwriting has remained loss-making for 12 years, while midyear rate increases have stayed close to the prior year’s level. The survey shows that cost pressure and pricing restraint are operating at the same time. It doesn’t establish whether future rate changes will be larger, whether underwriting results will improve, or how individual policyholders will fare. Any such claim would go beyond the information reported here.

For market participants, the practical question is how long premium growth can remain modest against rising claim severity while competition continues to constrain pricing. The available figures don’t answer that question. They do show why the average alone deserves caution: most reported rates were unchanged, but increases were more common than decreases, and the sector still recorded an underwriting loss.

(And this is the part most people overlook.) A rate increase and an underwriting recovery aren’t the same thing. One measures a change in price; the other depends on the relationship between premiums and losses and expenses. Still, the survey captures a market trying to reconcile those forces. Unevenly.

Further details are available at www.medicalliabilitymonitor.com.

Source: Gavin Souter · www.businessinsurance.com

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.