Monday, November 16, 2026Analysis · Ideas · Culture
nova.cloudejoys.com Search Sections

BANKING

Movement Mortgage Seeks $1.2M From Two Fired Chicago Originators

Published Nov 10, 2026967 readers

Movement Mortgage is seeking to confirm a $1.235 million arbitration award against two fired Chicago originators whose production collapsed after they joined.

Movement Mortgage Seeks $1.2M From Two Fired Chicago Originators

Movement Mortgage wants a federal court to enforce an arbitration award of at least $1,235,000 against two Chicago-based loan officers it fired in 2023. The amount is large by recent standards, and the case shows how a branch bet on a rate-sensitive market can turn into a costly dispute. Here's the thing: most coverage of mortgage layoffs focuses on headcount, not on what happens when a lender tries to get money back from people it already paid.

How the bet was placed

Victor Shkolnikov and Igor Velyunskiy were paid $835,000 and $400,000, respectively, in early 2022 to run a Chicago branch, according to case filings. A year later, the company terminated them after their production fell sharply. That timing matters. Mortgage rates were climbing fast, and the branch's volume went with them.

Hiring experienced producers to lead a branch is a common way lenders try to buy volume quickly. It's also a wager that the market will cooperate for as long as the pay package runs. When rates move the wrong way, that wager can sour before the lender has recouped what it spent.

The pair filed counterclaims, but an arbitrator rejected them at a hearing this summer. Movement says the award now carries 8% statutory interest running from the April 2023 firing, which could push the total higher. Interest that accrues from the termination date means the figure grows for as long as the dispute stays open. Whether a court ultimately enforces the award is a separate question from whether the award was right.

Both originators are still working in the industry. They didn't comment, and neither Movement nor its attorney responded to requests for comment. That leaves the public record thinner than the dollar figures suggest.

Production that never caught up

The lender says the branch lost money every month. Movement reports a negative $459,928 profit share for the pair and puts the Chicago branch's cost to the company at $350,281. Those figures come from Movement's side of the dispute, so treat them as the lender's account until something independent confirms them. Still, they line up with the volume story, which is why they're hard to dismiss.

The gap in volume is the real story here. Before joining Movement, the pair averaged about $36 million in origination volume per month. After they arrived, that dropped to roughly $4 million. Modex data shows output fell to only a few units a month by late 2022. That's a decline of close to nine-tenths, and it happened fast enough that a slow ramp-up doesn't explain it.

Rates explain part of the drop. The average 30-year fixed-rate mortgage rose from around 4% in March 2022 to the low-to-mid 6% range by April 2023, a stretch that hit purchase and refinance pipelines hard across the industry. Still, a branch that averages a fraction of its pre-hire output for most of its run is hard to defend on rates alone. (And this is the part most people overlook: a rate shock hits every lender, but it doesn't hit every branch equally.) The question that matters is how this branch performed against peers in the same market. The public case record doesn't answer that, and I'd be cautious about any conclusion that skips it.

The counterclaims and what they tested

The counterclaims targeted the terms of their employment agreement, including alleged violations of Regulation Z and state wage law tied to their compensation. The arbitrator denied all of them, citing the at-will language in the contract and a lack of evidence presented at the hearing.

Regulation Z is the federal rule that implements the Truth in Lending Act, and it includes restrictions on how loan originators can be compensated. State wage claims usually turn on how pay is defined, earned, and paid. Those are the kinds of questions that can get technical quickly, which is why the details of the contract matter so much.

Here's what I find telling: the at-will language did much of the work. Contract terms that let either side end the relationship shift the fight away from whether the firing was fair and toward what the contract actually promised. That's a narrower question, and it tends to favor whoever wrote the agreement.

A denial for lack of evidence isn't a finding that the company was right on the merits. It's a statement about what got presented in the room. If you're reading this as a precedent, that distinction is the one to hold onto.

A bigger pattern in clawbacks

Movement's cuts were not isolated. The company lost 15% of its producing workforce in 2023, with 349 originators leaving that year, according to Modex. It now has about 1,700 total employees and still ranks among the top lenders, with $13 billion in volume year to date. That reads as a company resizing its producer base rather than one in freefall, though the company's own statements are what drive that read.

Clawback fights have been a steady feature of the post-boom shakeout. In practice, a clawback is a demand that a former employee repay compensation already received, usually tied to production or tenure. The amount Movement is pursuing sits alongside some of the largest disclosed demands against former originators this decade. CrossCountry Mortgage, which has a history of pursuing these recoveries, sought as much as $2.1 million from one former employee. AnnieMac has also stepped up its pursuit of five- and six-figure sums, including $500,000 from a former branch manager.

Disclosed figures are a skewed sample, though. Cases that settle quietly rarely show up in filings or trade coverage, so the visible fights probably overstate how often these disputes reach a hearing. That said, the pattern is clear enough: lenders are increasingly willing to pursue former producers for money, and former producers are increasingly willing to contest it.

What this means for lenders and originators

For lenders, the lesson is about underwriting the people as much as the pipeline. Pay packages that look reasonable when rates are falling can become expensive when volume dries up. The mistake is treating a big upfront number as a sure thing rather than a bet with its own exit terms.

Watch whether more of these cases reach a judgment rather than settling. That will tell you how much recovery lenders can realistically expect. If most cases end in quiet settlements, the clawback threat is mostly a negotiating tool. If judgments start piling up, the math on big packages changes.

If you're an originator weighing a move to a branch with a large upfront package, read the termination and repayment terms as closely as the headline pay. And ask a lawyer who knows your state before you sign. Big numbers, thin public record.

Source: Andrew Martinez · www.nationalmortgagenews.com

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.