Monday, November 16, 2026Analysis · Ideas · Culture
nova.cloudejoys.com Search Sections

BANKING

Mortgage Servicers Watch for Shifts in Error Handling and Loss Mitigation

Published Nov 10, 2026876 readers

The final mortgage servicing rule is headed for review, and early signals point to a different approach from the 2023 proposal, especially on loss mitigation and servicing errors.

Mortgage Servicers Watch for Shifts in Error Handling and Loss Mitigation

Where the rule stands

Mortgage servicers may be bracing for a rule that looks nothing like the proposal they've been tracking. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has sent its mortgage servicing final rule to the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, an arm of President Trump's executive office. Here's the thing: this is the first real look at what the bureau intends to require, and the review is the step before any text goes public. OIRA review is a standard checkpoint for significant federal rules, and it's where the White House gets to weigh in before publication. That's why this stage matters more than it sounds. Servicers that planned around the original proposal are now working from signals, not drafts.

OIRA records show the bureau has submitted the final version of the rule that was proposed near the end of the Biden administration, according to Jonathan Kolodziej, partner at Bradley. The records also back up earlier Law360 reporting that the White House is reviewing the rule. The CFPB didn't respond to a request for comment. I'd read that last line as a yellow flag rather than a neutral detail. Silence from the agency doesn't tell you much about substance, but it does mean the most detailed view so far comes from an outside practitioner and from the paperwork, not from the bureau itself.

Jonathan Kolodziej

"We still don't know what is in the rule, but we do know that the CFPB is moving forward," Kolodziej said. He added that there's plenty of speculation about what the version the White House ultimately approves could contain. That's an honest summary, and you'll hear versions of it a lot in the coming weeks. Notice the split. The process is confirmed, but the content isn't. Anyone describing the rule's details with confidence is working from rumor, and that's the thing to keep in mind when you read commentary on it.

The executive order sets the direction

Much of that speculation centers on the servicing directives in President Trump's March executive order, which experts have said could reshape the bureau's role in the market. Several provisions call on the CFPB, the Department of Housing and Urban Development, the Federal Reserve, the National Credit Union Administration and banking regulators to update servicing rules. Among them: "cure-first standards" for "good-faith servicing errors," "simplifying loss mitigation requirements," and "aligning supervisory expectations to support portfolio mortgages servicing as a core community banking function." Read that last phrase twice. It suggests the order is concerned with portfolio lenders, meaning institutions that keep loans on their own books. Loss mitigation and error correction are where servicers spend much of their operational energy, so the wording points straight at the parts of the business that cost money.

"The rumor mill suggests that this final rule will not really look like what the proposal was," Kolodziej said. "The topics are the same, but the approach they take, as far as what they require servicers to do, is going to be very different." That distinction matters more than it first appears. A rule can keep the same subject headings and still rewrite every obligation underneath them. If you're tracking this by checking whether topics like error resolution or loss mitigation still show up, you'll miss the real change entirely. The test is what a servicer has to do, by when, and what happens if it doesn't.

The directives lean toward fixing errors before they become enforcement matters, and they favor pruning rules over adding them. That points toward a lighter touch. Still, a directive isn't a rule, and the gap between the two is where most of the uncertainty lives. The reporting puts the final rule within the next 90 days. Treat that as a possibility, not a schedule, since review timelines can stretch or compress without much warning.

Lighter in some areas, possibly heavier in others

The 2023 proposal was already streamlined compared with earlier CFPB servicing rules, which is worth remembering before you assume the new version has to be a rollback from something heavy. It also picked up feedback from the Mortgage Bankers Association, the Housing Policy Council and the American Bankers Association. That's a lot of industry input, and it means the proposal already reflected some of the complaints servicers had been raising. The administration could go further. Whether it does depends on how much of that feedback it accepts and how much it treats as a starting point to cut.

"I've heard various approaches that people think this administration might take. One of them is probably more deregulatory, deleting some existing provisions that are viewed as being problematic or overly complicating things. That would certainly be consistent," Kolodziej said. Pay attention to the hedges he built in. "Probably" and "might" are doing real work. Deletion is the simplest path for an agency that wants less regulation, since removing a provision doesn't require drafting a replacement. Still, deleting a rule is only as simple as the lender's systems allow. Servicers often built their processes around those provisions years ago, and unwinding them takes more than a line edit.

Still, some expect a mix: scaled-back rules in some places and new requirements in others. The logic is straightforward. Officials have reviewed a wide range of comments on the original proposal, and a wide range of comments rarely points in one direction. That's the part people tend to underestimate. Comment letters pull in every direction, so a final rule can be looser in one area and tighter in another without contradicting itself.

Kolodziej flagged a third possibility. "I have also heard some suggestions that they may take the current complex system of regulations and replace it with a new complex system of regulations. That's a big question out there." This is the scenario that should worry anyone hoping for simplicity. Swapping one dense rulebook for another can look like reform on paper while leaving compliance teams with the same workload. The new text would need to be learned from scratch, and that cost usually lands on operations staff who already know the old rules well.

For servicers, the question isn't only whether the rule gets lighter. It's which provisions survive. Loss mitigation and error-correction requirements are the pieces most likely to change how a servicing shop runs day to day. A rewrite there can alter staffing, software, and the way borrowers are triaged, even if the total page count drops.

What this means for servicers and borrowers

If you're working in servicing, the practical advice is dull but useful: don't reorganize around a draft nobody has published. Track the error-correction and loss-mitigation provisions closely, because that's where operational change tends to show up first. Lighter doesn't automatically mean simpler, and simpler doesn't mean cheaper.

My read is that the word "deregulation" understates the uncertainty here. The structure of the final text, not its length, will determine what servicers spend on compliance. Lighter in tone. Murkier in substance.

For borrowers, the stakes are indirect but real. Cure-first standards and loss mitigation changes affect how quickly a struggling homeowner gets a fix, and how often a small servicing error grows into a bigger problem. Those outcomes won't show up in a headline, but they're where the rule will actually be felt.

What comes next is the OIRA review, then publication, then whatever comments and challenges follow. None of those steps are guaranteed to match the timeline in the reporting. Watch the published text rather than the speculation, and you'll know more than most of the people commenting on it.

Source: Bonnie Sinnock · www.nationalmortgagenews.com

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.